Originally Posted by
twentyone
Something else I would like to point out. Everyone says how lop sided the Brayden schenn trade was. He had 57 points in 29 games to finish the year. Yes they were swept in the 2nd round to the eventual WHL champs. But let's look at what they gave up.
2011 1st rnd (22nd overall) Jordan Papirny, top 3 goalie in AAA Ab
2011 2nd rnd (44th overal)
Hawryluk, top 16 year old goal scorer in dub2012 1st rnd (13th overall)
Schmyr, On All star team at western U16's
2012 1st rnd import - (38th overall) - wouldn't of used it anyway. Nezjleb
Tim McCauley - having a pretty good year. 2nd line center already
Artyn Nikkel - seems to have been overrated. Traded for Walters, 4th round pick by St. Louis, and Sanhein, 8th scoerer in the Mb AAA league
None of those picks are high enough to be locks. And of the two prospects they traded the higher rated prospect hasn't
done much and has already been traded. To me it was worth the shot at bringing schenn in and trying to win a cup.
I personally don't think Lorne overpaid as much as other say he did.
I would agree Lorne should have taken a shot, but to say he didn't overpay beggers belief. Look at what Brandon got in return. Already 2 guys are our top 2 centers, Papirny and Schmyr will both make the team next season, Nezjleb is a serviceable Euro, and we ended up with a #3 defenceman in Walters, Sanheim, the jury is out. It's nice to be a fan and support your team and all, but remember, that traded netted you 2 more playoff wins than Brandon! And if you think Hawryluk isn't a lock to be a WHL star, well, we should probably fund together on the board and buy you some glasses!
Never argue with idiots, they just drag you down to their level then beat you with experience.